Fat Baby's Pizza & Subs

Reviews about Fat Baby's Pizza & Subs

• 5 / 5

  By Jeffrey Brunner
  I LOVED THE PIZZA!!! I had been craving a real authentic New York style pizza for weeks and Fat Baby's delivered. Huge authentic slices and great quality ingredients. The owner even came by and introduced himself and made sure everything was top notch. Good beer selection too. Will be back next time I'm in the Hilton Head area.
  February 20, 2017
• 1 / 5

  By Ashlan Masterson
  Terrible experience. First, we walked in and it took us 5 minutes to even get greeted (not busy, the only ones waiting). The guy behind the bar and wait staff all stared at us that whole time that I'm guessing they were wondering whose job it was to greet us. We had a party of 9, there was 3 tables of 5 opened (two right next to each other that could have been put together) and there was a party of ten there already where they already put two tables together. They told us we would have to sit separately. We said no. Then they said they'll see if they can figure something out. We waited and decided to go to Mellow Mushroom (where they were so nice and accommodating!)
  December 18, 2016